Jump to a section
Chatbots can drift towards flattery: OpenAI rolled back a 2025 ChatGPT update for being 'overly flattering and agreeable'. To get real feedback, don't ask whether something is good. Ask for the weaknesses, give it a critical role, hide that the work is yours, ask for the case against, and make it rank its points. Then you decide which criticism to act on.
Why it tends to agree with you
In April 2025, OpenAI rolled back a ChatGPT update after users noticed it praising almost everything, including bad ideas. OpenAI said the update was 'overly flattering and agreeable', and explained that it had leaned too heavily on short-term feedback, producing responses that were 'overly supportive but disingenuous', TechCrunch reported.
That was an extreme case, and OpenAI fixed it. But it shows how easily a chatbot can slide towards pleasing you. If you want criticism, ask for it clearly.
TechCrunch: OpenAI explains why ChatGPT became too sycophantic (April 2025)
Five ways to ask that work
Each of these makes criticism the job, rather than a risk:
- Ask for problems, not a verdict: 'what are the three weakest points?' beats 'is this good?'
- Give it a critical role: a tough editor, a sceptical buyer, the person who'll read it
- Hide that it's yours: 'a friend wrote this' removes the urge to be nice
- Ask for the opposite case: 'argue against this plan as strongly as you can'
- Make it rank: 'which one change would improve this most?' stops a long list of nitpicks
For something you've written
A CV, a complaint letter, a speech, a story. Tell it who will read it.
Act as a tough but fair editor. This was written by someone else, for [WHO WILL READ IT], with the goal of [GOAL]. List the three biggest weaknesses, quoting the exact sentences, and explain why each one hurts the goal. Then tell me the single change that would help most. Don't rewrite it and don't soften the criticism.
[PASTE IT]For a plan or decision
Buying a car, moving house, starting a side project. Make it argue the other side before you commit.
I'm planning to [YOUR PLAN] because [YOUR REASONS]. Argue as strongly as you can that this is a mistake. What am I missing, what could go wrong, and what would I wish I'd checked first?Imagine it's a year from now and [YOUR PLAN] went badly. Write the three most likely reasons why, then tell me what I could do now to prevent each one.You still decide
Asked to be critical, a chatbot may find fault even when the work is fine. Treat its points as suggestions to weigh, not orders. If a criticism doesn't ring true, ask it to explain, or ignore it.
Sources
These sources support the guide. Tool settings, prices and policies change, so dated source boxes show when those details were checked.
AI helps with research and drafting. Dan checks the sources and is responsible for what is published.
How we check